以下是引用疏影暗香在2007-11-13 17:50:00的发言：

这个话有倾向性.

我就觉得,是懂了所以才不屑. 要是没懂,觉得是个3级片, 肯定击节叫好呢, 伟仔连OO都露了, 怎么能不好?

agree

It's funny that when I talk about the flaws of the movie itself , several IDs began to talk about history and politics.

I said that anti-Japan is not about politics  ,it's about fighting against invaders.

Then they began to say that you don't understand movie.

What the hell is that that?

I'm so confused.

I'll keep repeating my views again and again

我们就是靠咀嚼虚无，战胜虚无的。

　　都是简单的道理，看很多影评拼命分析，越分析越复杂，觉得好可笑。

 王佳芝 suffered from everyone around her ,not only her family, her relatives, her first love( Mr. Kuang), her classmates, and also Old Wu, except Old YI .  

That’s it.

We see the whole picture without any historical or political view. 

We see the whole picture without any historical or political view. 

　其实这故事结局大家早就知道了，最大的看点是看李导怎么把这事儿给说圆了，这压根就是假命题，所以说李安确实厉害，在前面就用种种质疑和模糊了所谓“爱国”行动的意义

That's why I don't like this movie.

The topic itself is way too old and so not natural.

The story teller himself dosen't have the confidence to complete the story. He had to push it to the extreme to make you agree that this woman has lust of being loved.

 张爱玲自己一家都是汉奸，不只前夫胡兰成是辅助汪精卫的汉奸，外曾祖父李鸿章也是.She made up a story to go defense for her past history and An LEE helped her to extend it.

[此贴子已经被作者于2007-11-14 16:20:12编辑过]