I would not recommend the first one. I had it in a gift set last year. It's too rich and creamy. Half the day off, i still felt it on my face in stead of "in" it. The whole bottile is still some where in my drawer. my skin is combination to normal.
But skin care stuff always works wierd. one's poison is another's honey. You got to try it by yourself before you know if it's right for you.