apple2025 发表于 2025-01-19 14:03

只要一个标准严格挑选的，不会差

问题是真的按一个标准来选，某种肤色的根本选不上的

亚裔教授才是被歧视的那个吧！告她。

akebaby 发表于 2025-01-19 16:04

问题是真的按一个标准来选，某种肤色的根本选不上的

别瞎说

也别觉得华人就特别厉害

我带过一个黑人博后，已经AP三年了。极佳。每一次Meeting都是完整的结果，summary， 外加问题 和 下一步工作的思考。我的感觉，就是被 TA 推着走。我曾经有一个大陆华人博士生，考试不错，科研完全不上路子，一路带着，博士论文初稿到手一看，我眼前一黑，差点摔倒。后来就是完全改80%帮TA重写。

所以，在美国不要种族歧视，每个族裔都有厉害的人，也有不厉害的人。但是Biden政府推行DEI是完全错误的。

ecaeca 发表于 2025-01-19 10:22

这篇报道的原始英文版见这里。

https://www.wbez.org/education/2025/01/16/a-black-student-at-uchicago-says-she-experienced-racial-discrimination-now-her-phd-is-at-risk

很奇怪文章中声称“戴维斯来自一所传统黑人学校，在那里她是众多黑人女性中的一员。“Davis came from a historically Black college, where she was one of many Black women.” 然而戴维斯自己的学生网页上显示她的Undergraduate Institution是University Of Texas At San Antonio，并不是一所historically Black college

https://neurograd.uchicago.edu/program/students/gianna-davis

另外，“导师在学生的学术生涯中扮演着至关重要的角色，但他们很少接受关于如何有效进行教学和指导的系统培训，尤其是当面对文化背景迥异、成长经历不同的学生时，这种缺失就显得尤为突出。” 这在英文版本中是University of Wisconsin-Madison心理系教授Angela Byars-Winston接受采访时的观点。不知为何中文版本把这个人和她的其他不少言论都删掉了。Angela Byars-Winston的主页见下面：

https://www.medicine.wisc.edu/directory/byars-winston_angela

中文的内容跟这个英文链接里头的有点不一样。英文里头有些细节也没具体说。

没有提到沉重的仪器，只是说不需要动脑的工作

Davis said, he singled her out for menial tasks that he did not assign to her non-Black labmates, like moving boxes on the weekends — and made comments implying she was incompetent. He told her, she said, to prepare for when she failed out of the program.

学校的信里 提到她是Strong student，跟上面incompetent的阐述也不太一致

But last fall, she got an email notifying her that she was being placed on academic probation. The email said that while she is a strong student, her faculty adviser would no longer work with her due to “irreconcilable differences.” Davis was given a few days to pack up the things on her desk, including the plaque with her dad’s obituary. If she does not find a new advisor and research project, she will lose her spot at the university.

学校的email说她是"strong student"只是模板客气话，就像拒信往往写“We have to turn down a large number of very strong candidates”一样。那封信就是通知她导师不再带她了。