德川咪咪
2015年我曾报道过一桩虐童案，一个农村家庭，父乞母疯，精神病母亲在喂奶时疯病发作，用剪刀将亲生孩子扎了一百多刀。当时的注意力集中在如何启动社会送养机制，帮助这一家的三个孩子摆脱困局。
这几天被徐州八孩事件唤起了这桩遥远的回忆，我又回去重新看了一下这篇文章，发现一个毛骨悚然的事实：同样的徐州丰县、同样乞讨的父亲（这里的“父亲”甚至是三兄弟）、同样“捡”来的疯母亲……我惊觉当年在叙事中被忽视的母亲才是一个更残酷的现实，那就是，徐州丰县拐卖妇女绝非孤例，而存在着长期的、系统性、习俗性的犯罪现象。
当时的报道手记： https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/20845970
berlin 发表于 2022-02-09 00:30
看这个知乎的评论，只能说这个记者实在是缺乏思考和发现问题的能力，下面的网友只是看了她的文章就能马上指出真正的问题在哪里，而她却是在6年以后恍然大悟。。。里面她描述的王琴琴怎么对弟弟，放到美国，大多能很快反应出来怎么回事吧
zz 丰县警匪，奴隶社会 https://weibo.com/tv/show/1034:4734615055958054
那啥啥一家名言：
就你这点力量算啥？闹不起来！
特别是几个挑头的，肯定被抓！
帖子里的姐妹们很了不起，再看隔壁还有叫周知方归化来发展的。 唉，人与人对实物的见解何其不同。
这事解决之前我是绝不可能去中国的。虽然人家不差我一个人，但是我想到了另一个引起注意的方法--我们要不要筹钱打广告？或者在旅游网站引起注意？
又一个网上几年前的帖子 佐证丰县八孩妈的问题不是个案
我对骄傲女孩持观望态度 因为没有第三方印证她们的行为和立场 但是就像土工的策略一样 要团结所有能团结的力量 即使她们有自己的目的和立场 在这件事上如果她们的某个行为做的对八娃妈和类似受害者有利那我就支持那个行为
bananamm 发表于 2022-02-08 23:53
同感，骄傲女孩说收集了dna这件事很突兀，时间上来看应该早就收了，为什么现在忽然说，结果早就该有了，为什么一定要寄境外，那么多件分几处验一验早就出结果了
又一个网上几年前的帖子 佐证丰县八孩妈的问题不是个案
bananamm 发表于 2022-02-09 00:44
好心收留精神不正常妇女一起养娃，真是丰县不变的传统啊。。。
同感，骄傲女孩说收集了dna这件事很突兀，时间上来看应该早就收了，为什么现在忽然说，结果早就该有了，为什么一定要寄境外，那么多件分几处验一验早就出结果了
hippogirl 发表于 2022-02-09 00:44
这些倒是能解释 anyway 不想多讨论她们 免得模糊了重点被水军钻空子
这事解决之前我是绝不可能去中国的。虽然人家不差我一个人，但是我想到了另一个引起注意的方法--我们要不要筹钱打广告？或者在旅游网站引起注意？
AlwaysHopeful 发表于 2022-02-09 00:41
捐钱这个在华人上曾经搞得比较ugly 我其实有想过能不能把网上一些关于这个案子的图片印在t shirt上穿 但是怕侵犯版权问题 不知道如果就是自己花钱印了自己穿 是不是能避免版权问题
好心收留精神不正常妇女一起养娃，真是丰县不变的传统啊。。。
trayanh 发表于 2022-02-09 00:47
而且精神病妈妈们生的娃都没有精神病 真是神奇
大家不要轻易怀疑骄傲女孩，她们已经做了太多别人不敢做的事了，如果没有确切的证据，我们还是要相信她们的努力和勇敢。
向楼里写信和修改信件以及还在关注这事的各位致敬...
大家不要轻易怀疑骄傲女孩，她们已经做了太多别人不敢做的事了，如果没有确切的证据，我们还是要相信她们的努力和勇敢。
wxfxb 发表于 2022-02-09 01:00
她们确实很勇敢 我自问做不到
除州丰县这么多好心收留走失的精神病妇女的案子！毛骨悚然！你们这帮当官的,良心都被狗吞了吗？不怕遭报应？！
除州丰县这么多好心收留走失的精神病妇女的案子！毛骨悚然！你们这帮当官的,良心都被狗吞了吗？不怕遭报应？！
lnghng 发表于 2022-02-09 01:07
然后都办了户口和结婚证，简直是一条龙服务啊
徐州这次“芳名”远扬啊，为了生命安全，年轻姑娘们出差都得绕开啊。
有可能 她对国内情况肯定更了解 也肯定想到了可能的后果 权衡之后发声更值得尊敬
bananamm 发表于 2022-02-09 00:17
她怎么可能发声？纽时想采访她，她的条件是问题要先提交，发表前也要审核，所以最后就没采访成。她绝对不会说任何让政府不高兴的话
根据大家的意见作了修改。我们可以一起签名寄送UNHRC，或用于petition。
To the United Nations Human Rights Council:
We are calling on the council for an urgent investigation into the human trafficking, sex enslaving, and a heinous human rights violation case in Xuzhou, China. A woman, who is believed to be Ying Li, was a victim of human trafficking since 12, and has been a sex slave of a man who not only raped her but also had 8 children with her. She is seen in the picture locked up with an industrial chain, covered with a thin layer in winter in a scruffy hut. The horrid fact is, Ying is not the only sex slave in the village. Evidence shows that there are at least several other women in the same if not worse situation.
Around Jan 29, an internet post raised the attention of the public. A man, Zhimin Dong, is showing off his 8 kids and government subsidy he received on Tik-Tok. People noticed that in the background, there''s a woman shackled in a squalid place, a hut with no isolation in winter. Dong claimed his wife, the woman in the picture, is mentally sick. The incident soon raised internet rage. Is it legal to chain up any individual in captivity? Was she mentally unwell before they were married, in which case the woman can be considered as nonconsensual? And most importantly, was she abducted?
Two days later, the local government issued a statement saying that Xia Yang(the woman) was a local villager with mental disease, and that she was married to Dong in 1998. "There was no abduction and she is locked up to keep people safe."
Soon, a grassroot volunteer organization discovered that a girl who was abducted on the way to school and claimed missing has undeniably identical features to Xia. The girl Ying was taken in 1996 at the age of 12, and is believed to be a human trafficking victim. Her family is still looking for her. With the look, the year missing, and all other details match, it is widely believed that Xia is indeed Ying.
People who are related to the area or who have obtained information about the village stepped out with more information. The girl was "bought" by Dong''s family from the traffickers, and used by the father and 2 sons sexually, one of which is Dong. Some local officials participated in raping as well. Xia was obstinate and never fawned at the rapists. She fought back with teeth and kicks. In order to make her more "obedient", Dong knocked off her teeth. One person also said that Xia was drugged to lose her voice.
The local government then issued another statement, saying they have compared with the DNA pool and Xia is not a registered missing person.
By then, Ying''''''''s mother has requested a DNA comparison with Xia, which is never granted. Xia is kept in a place no outsiders can approach to get a sample.
More truth swarmed in, stupefying the already gasping public. Villages around Xuzhou have a history of being one of the destinations of human trafficking. In the 80s, during the year 1986 to 1989, there were 40,000 human trafficking victims bought by the villagers as sex slaves. A rough calculation shows, today there are around 20,000 sex slaves in those villages. Human trafficking in Xuzhou has an industrial complex behind it. Unmarried guys can pay around 3,000 to 6,000 Yuan (around $500 to $1,000) to get a girl. The local government then created a new ID for the girl, and too marriage licenses. The new household then can claim government subsidy. Of course, sex slaves do fight back. They will get beaten up, drugged, or inhumanely tortured as a result. There''s another woman "living" next to Xia''s, is crawling on the ground in a more grubby hut. Her knees were knocked to pieces from an attempted run-away. Another one is hung to get beaten every other day. Some of them went insane in the living hell. About half of the rescued sex slaves are diagnosed of having mental illness.
Another question also emerged among all. There''s a ten-year gap between Xia''s 1st son and 2nd son. Xia has 7 boys and 1 girl, youngest 1 year old. The chance of getting such probability is thin. People suppose Xia has/had other kids. They could be girls. But no one could get a chance to talk to Xia. The village is sealed.
It is palpable by now that the Xuzhou local government has served as a shield in the human trafficking business. On the provincial level, neither Ying''s birth place nor Xuzhou''s governing province has uttered a sound despite the fuming lambasting from the public.
On Feb 7, the central government semi-officially stated that Xia has been identified. She is a woman of 52, from Yunnan Province, who was taken to treat her mental disease 20 years ago and got missing. She has no living relatives.
The public is giving backlash. Apparently, the numbers don''t add up. There''s no photographic or witness evidence either.
Till then, Ying''s mother''s DNA request is still not granted.
To date, Xia is segregated and confined to a mental institution, no volunteer or social worker allowed to visit. The truth is prevented to be found out by the state apparatus.
According to all the information gleaned so far, Xia is not simply a psychotic woman who is not treated properly. There''s much more behind it. The whole occurrence is not only a human rights violation case, but a consortium of crimes on multiple levels with unfathomable magnitudes. Xia was abducted, human trafficked, raped, sexually abused and assaulted, used as a reproductive machine, manhandled, and much more.
Let''s ask a few questions:
- Why isn''t a DNA comparison approved?
- Why can''t Ying''s mother meet Xia to find out what she remembers?
- Why isn''t the local government answering on what base did they issued the press releases that are contradicting each other?
- How many more women like Xia are there in the same village? Same city? Same province?
- What is being done to help them?
In so, we urgently request that the counsel send out an independent investigation panel to evaluate the situation. With human trafficking as a protected business, women in China as a collective group is facing danger. The state apparatus is failing us.
We feel for Xia. Any human being''s heart would pain at such hideous crime. She is our daughter, sister, cousin... She was us. Remember, she, a sweet teenage girl much loved and cared for, was on her way to school one day, suddenly blacked out, and woke up in a living hell, with no one there to help. It could happen to anyone if we can''t find out the truth.
We want the truth. We need the truth.
Appendix
- photo comparison of Xia and Ying
- Photo of Xia chained to the hut
- the next door woman crawling on the mud ground
- Ying''s uncle''s letter
- Volunteer organization Proud Girl''s photo evidence
养貂的小昭 发表于 2022-02-08 22:06
非常谢谢热心网友！有几个小建议，仅供参考。我把我加的词语放在括号里：
第一段：
had “at least” 8 children
Ying is not the only “trafficked” sex slave in the village
第四段：
discovered that a girl “named Ying Li”, who was abducted on the way to school and claimed missing